We undertook a thorough analysis of 24-hour urine collections from over 6,200 participants to explore how various urinary factors contribute to kidney stone formation.
Our findings revealed that higher levels of urine volume, citrate, potassium, magnesium, and uric acid were linked to a lower risk of developing stones. Conversely, increased levels of calcium, oxalate, phosphorus, and sodium were associated with a higher risk.
Interestingly, urine acidity did not seem to play a role. Our research highlighted the complexity and varying importance of these urinary factors regarding their relationship with stone formation.
Read More
7
Citrate beverage shows promise
Effect of a high-citrate beverage on urine chemistry in patients with calcium kidney stones.
We explored the effects of a low-calorie, high-citrate beverage named Moonstone on patients with calcium kidney stones. Administered twice daily, this drink increased urine citrate levels and pH while reducing calcium oxalate levels compared to plain water.
While this drink was well-received and tolerated by participants, the benefits seen are similar to those from potassium-magnesium citrate. Although promising, more research is needed to confirm its efficacy in reducing kidney stones in broader patient groups.
Read More
7
Calcium citrate lowers kidney stones
Pharmacotherapy and Stone Mineral Subtype Influence Long-Term Recurrence Rates in Calcium Stone Formers.
We investigated whether calcium citrate treatment helps prevent kidney stones over a long period. Our analysis followed patients with calcium stones for up to 12 years, focusing on how medical therapy, like calcium citrate, impacts stone recurrence.
We found that patients treated with calcium citrate, particularly those forming calcium-oxalate stones, showed lower recurrence rates after about five years. This delay in seeing benefits is crucial for understanding how we can plan future treatments.
Read More
Most Useful Reviews
7.5
Prevents kidney stones
4 people found this helpful
Best Absorbable Form of Calcium Why did I choose this particular calcium? Because my dietitian advised me to take calcium citrate as it is the least likely to contribute to the formation of kidney stones. This is the most optimal form of calcium. Additionally, the composition also contains vitamin D2, zinc, copper, magnesium and manganese. However, consider this if you are consuming other supplements to avoid overdose! It is recommended to take two tablets daily, ideally at different times. For instance, in the morning and afternoon. At night - it's not recommended, due to rapid mineral salt release from the body. Adults only should use this. The only drawback for me is the size of the oblong-shaped tablets - 2.4 cm long. I also struggle to swallow pills, needing to drink and eat to prevent choking on them. If my review is helpful, please like it ๐๐
Read More
7.5
Highly absorbed calcium
3 people found this helpful
Good calcium! Calcium citrate is the optimal dosage form, absorbed by the body much better than calcium carbonate (which is more commonly sold in pharmacies). A key feature of calcium citrate is its low ability to form kidney stones, which is significant with prolonged use. As mineral salts are released from the body more quickly at night, it's advisable to take calcium supplements after lunch and in the evening. It's best to drink it with water and never tea!
Read More
9
Energy cycle assistance
1 people found this helpful
Excellent! Calcium citrate not only has high digestibility but offers numerous advantages. It reduces calcium excretion in urine, prevents kidney stones by alkalising urine, and aids in the absorption of vitamin C and minerals while participating in cellular energy cycles. I am pleased with my purchase and its benefits.
Magnesium supplements benefit kidney stone formers
Effect of magnesium oxide or citrate supplements on metabolic risk factors in kidney stone formers with idiopathic hyperoxaluria: a randomized clinical trial.
We evaluated how magnesium oxide and magnesium citrate supplements affect kidney stone formers with high oxalate levels. In a rigorous study with 90 participants, we found that both supplements helped lower oxalate excretion and calcium oxalate supersaturation when compared to a placebo.
Notably, magnesium citrate showed even stronger results, especially for those with normal urine magnesium levels. While both options are effective in reducing potential kidney stone risks, magnesium citrate may offer an edge in certain patients.
Read More
8
Urinary factors impact kidney stone risk
24-Hour Urinary Chemistries and Kidney Stone Risk.
We undertook a thorough analysis of 24-hour urine collections from over 6,200 participants to explore how various urinary factors contribute to kidney stone formation.
Our findings revealed that higher levels of urine volume, citrate, potassium, magnesium, and uric acid were linked to a lower risk of developing stones. Conversely, increased levels of calcium, oxalate, phosphorus, and sodium were associated with a higher risk.
Interestingly, urine acidity did not seem to play a role. Our research highlighted the complexity and varying importance of these urinary factors regarding their relationship with stone formation.
Read More
8
Combined therapies for kidney stones
Synergistic inhibition of calcium oxalate crystal formation and synergistic protection of HK-2 cells from crystal damage by sulfated polysaccharide and potassium citrate.
We investigated how combining sulfated polysaccharides with potassium citrate could inhibit calcium oxalate (CaOx) crystal formation and protect kidney cells.
Our study utilized various additive groups to compare their effectiveness. Excitingly, the combination of sulfated compounds and potassium citrate showed an impressive increase in their protective effects on renal cells and their capability to prevent crystal aggregation.
Particularly, the SDLP-Kcit combination stood out as an effective option for treating kidney stones, outpacing standalone treatments. This suggests a promising avenue for future kidney stone therapies.
Read More
7
Calcium citrate lowers kidney stones
Pharmacotherapy and Stone Mineral Subtype Influence Long-Term Recurrence Rates in Calcium Stone Formers.
We investigated whether calcium citrate treatment helps prevent kidney stones over a long period. Our analysis followed patients with calcium stones for up to 12 years, focusing on how medical therapy, like calcium citrate, impacts stone recurrence.
We found that patients treated with calcium citrate, particularly those forming calcium-oxalate stones, showed lower recurrence rates after about five years. This delay in seeing benefits is crucial for understanding how we can plan future treatments.
Read More
7
Citrate beverage shows promise
Effect of a high-citrate beverage on urine chemistry in patients with calcium kidney stones.
We explored the effects of a low-calorie, high-citrate beverage named Moonstone on patients with calcium kidney stones. Administered twice daily, this drink increased urine citrate levels and pH while reducing calcium oxalate levels compared to plain water.
While this drink was well-received and tolerated by participants, the benefits seen are similar to those from potassium-magnesium citrate. Although promising, more research is needed to confirm its efficacy in reducing kidney stones in broader patient groups.
Read More
User Reviews
USERS' SCORE
Good
Based on 11 Reviews
8.2
All Reviews
Positive Reviews
Negative Reviews
7.5
Prevents kidney stones
4 people found this helpful
Best Absorbable Form of Calcium Why did I choose this particular calcium? Because my dietitian advised me to take calcium citrate as it is the least likely to contribute to the formation of kidney stones. This is the most optimal form of calcium. Additionally, the composition also contains vitamin D2, zinc, copper, magnesium and manganese. However, consider this if you are consuming other supplements to avoid overdose! It is recommended to take two tablets daily, ideally at different times. For instance, in the morning and afternoon. At night - it's not recommended, due to rapid mineral salt release from the body. Adults only should use this. The only drawback for me is the size of the oblong-shaped tablets - 2.4 cm long. I also struggle to swallow pills, needing to drink and eat to prevent choking on them. If my review is helpful, please like it ๐๐
Read More
7.5
Highly absorbed calcium
3 people found this helpful
Good calcium! Calcium citrate is the optimal dosage form, absorbed by the body much better than calcium carbonate (which is more commonly sold in pharmacies). A key feature of calcium citrate is its low ability to form kidney stones, which is significant with prolonged use. As mineral salts are released from the body more quickly at night, it's advisable to take calcium supplements after lunch and in the evening. It's best to drink it with water and never tea!
Read More
9
Energy cycle assistance
1 people found this helpful
Excellent! Calcium citrate not only has high digestibility but offers numerous advantages. It reduces calcium excretion in urine, prevents kidney stones by alkalising urine, and aids in the absorption of vitamin C and minerals while participating in cellular energy cycles. I am pleased with my purchase and its benefits.
Read More
9
No kidney stones
Drank for prevention. All is well. No kidney stones have arisen. Feeling good, you can take it.
Read More
7.5
Normalised calcium levels
Excellent product! I ordered this for my mother, who is prone to kidney stones and had worsening osteoporosis. After about a year of use, her lab results showed normalised calcium levels and improved tests for bone metabolism, halting osteoporosis progression. A fantastic product!
Kidney stones are hard deposits made of minerals and salts that form inside your kidneys. While they can vary in size from tiny particles to large stones, they all begin as crystallized substances that develop when urine contains more crystal-forming substances than the fluid in your urine can dilute. When the crystals stick together, they can form stones, which may cause severe pain, especially when they pass through the urinary tract. Common types of kidney stones include calcium stones, struvite stones, uric acid stones, and cystine stones.
The symptoms of kidney stones can include sharp pain in the side and back, pain during urination, pink or red urine, and frequent urination. Various factors can increase the risk of developing kidney stones, including dehydration, certain dietary choices, and genetic predisposition. Preventing kidney stones often involves drinking plenty of water, avoiding excessive salt and animal protein, and ensuring a balanced intake of calcium. For those who suffer from kidney stones, a medical evaluation may be necessary to determine the best management and preventive strategies.
Calcium citrate is a calcium salt of citric acid, widely used as a dietary supplement to provide an additional source of calcium for individuals who may not get enough of this essential mineral from their diets. It is particularly popular for its enhanced bioavailability, which means that the body can absorb calcium from calcium citrate more effectively than from other forms of calcium, such as calcium carbonate. This supplement is especially beneficial for those with decreased stomach acid, such as older adults, as it does not require acid for absorption.
In addition to aiding in bone health, calcium plays a crucial role in muscle function, nerve transmission, and blood clotting. Typically, calcium citrate is available in tablet and powder forms, making it easy to incorporate into daily routines. It’s important to follow dosing recommendations and possibly consult with a healthcare provider before starting any supplement regimen to ensure it meets individual dietary needs and health objectives.
Calcium citrate is often recommended as a dietary supplement for individuals prone to kidney stones. Unlike other forms of calcium, calcium citrate may actually help reduce the formation of certain types of stones, particularly calcium oxalate stones, which are the most common type of kidney stone. The reason for this is that citrate can bind with calcium in the urine, reducing the amount of free calcium available to combine with oxalate. This biochemical interaction can decrease the risk of stone formation and may even help break down existing stones.
In addition to its protective effects, calcium citrate is easily absorbed and does not depend on stomach acid for absorption, making it a preferable option for those who might have issues with gastrointestinal acidity. However, it’s important to consult with a healthcare provider before starting any supplement, especially if you have a history of kidney stones. A healthcare professional can provide tailored advice based on your individual health needs and dietary habits, ensuring that you're taking the appropriate steps in managing your kidney stone risk.
Based on user reviews, the time frame for seeing results from taking calcium citrate supplements, particularly for kidney stones, can vary. Some users report experiencing benefits in as little as a month, with one user stating their mother took calcium citrate for about a month, suggesting it may have a noticeable effect within that period Read Review. Others, like a user who reported their mother normalized calcium levels and improved bone metabolism after about a year, indicate a longer usage period may be required for more significant benefits Read Review.
Overall, many users emphasize the importance of ongoing use for the prevention of kidney stones, with some mentioning they felt a sense of relief or prevention within months of starting the supplement Read Review. Hence, while benefits can potentially manifest fairly quickly, continuous use seems crucial for optimal results in preventing kidney stone formation.
The research surrounding supplements for kidney stones indicates a promising landscape for certain compounds. A study involving magnesium supplements, specifically magnesium citrate, showed significant benefits in lowering oxalate excretion and calcium oxalate supersaturation among kidney stone formers, suggesting that magnesium citrate may be particularly effective for those with normal urine magnesium levels [1]. Additionally, calcium citrate has been demonstrated to reduce recurrence rates of calcium-oxalate stones over a long-term period, marking its potential as a preventative treatment [2].
Moreover, findings indicate that urinary factors, including higher levels of potassium and magnesium, are associated with a lower risk of stone formation [3]. Other innovative approaches, such as a low-calorie, high-citrate beverage named Moonstone, have also shown promise in increasing urine citrate levels and reducing calcium oxalate levels, though further research is needed [4]. The combination of polysaccharides and potassium citrate has also been highlighted as a potent means of inhibiting calcium oxalate crystal formation [5]. Overall, there is scientific support for the use of specific supplements in managing and preventing kidney stones.
Users have reported a range of symptom improvements when taking calcium citrate supplements, particularly in relation to kidney stone prevention and bone health. Many found that calcium citrate is an advantageous choice due to its higher absorbability compared to other forms, such as calcium carbonate. For example, one user noted an improvement in their mother's osteoporosis after a year of consistency, where lab results showed normalized calcium levels and a halt in disease progression Read Review. Additionally, some users remarked on the supplement's effectiveness in maintaining good urinary health, with one stating that since starting the daily regimen, they have not experienced kidney stones Read Review.
Other users reported overall satisfaction with the supplement's effects on their wellness. They appreciated that it reduces calcium excretion in urine, which minimizes the risk of stone formation and also aids in the absorption of other nutrients like vitamin C Read Review. While individual experiences can differ, the prevailing sentiment among users suggests that calcium citrate might be especially beneficial for those concerned with kidney stone formation or managing osteoporosis.
Users have reported mixed feedback regarding the combination of calcium citrate supplements with other supplements to manage kidney stones. Several reviews emphasize that calcium citrate is preferable due to its high absorbability and lower likelihood of contributing to kidney stone formation compared to other calcium forms like calcium carbonate Read Review. However, some users caution against potential vitamin and mineral overload, particularly when combining calcium with other supplements. One reviewer explicitly notes the importance of spacing doses, suggesting that taking them at different times might help avoid excessive intake of certain minerals Read Review.
Additionally, there are instances where users have combined calcium citrate with magnesium and vitamin D, indicating this combination may enhance its effectiveness in preventing kidney stones and improving overall bone health Read Review. One pharmacist reviewer recommended calcium citrate to avoid complications associated with inorganic salts, reinforcing its role in a balanced supplement regimen Read Review. Ultimately, while many users find calcium citrate beneficial and align it with other supplements, they also suggest exercising caution regarding dosage and timing to ensure optimal health benefits.
Based on user reviews, many users reported that the optimal dosage for Calcium Citrate in treating or preventing kidney stones is generally around one to two tablets daily, divided into different doses throughout the day to enhance absorption and minimize the risk of adverse effects. For example, one user mentioned taking two tablets daily, ideally after lunch and in the afternoon, to ensure better utilization of the supplement and to avoid rapid mineral release at night Read Review. Another user, a pharmacist, recommended a single tablet daily for osteoporosis prevention, highlighting that this dosage worked well without causing issues typically associated with other forms of calcium Read Review.
Users also noted that Calcium Citrate is preferable due to its high digestibility and lower tendency to contribute to kidney stone formation. Some users reported feeling no adverse side effects and attributed successful prevention of kidney stones to their use of Calcium Citrate Read Review. It’s essential to consult with a healthcare professional before starting any supplement regimen to determine the right dosage suited for individual health needs.
6
Low kidney stone risk
Calcium citrate is among the most digestible forms of this mineral and aids in preventing kidney stones! My mother and I took calcium citrate and it lasted about a month. It's best consumed in the afternoon, around 7 or 8 pm. Itโs a good form of calcium, but I won't repurchase it. Calcium works best with magnesium and vitamin D3, hence Iโll focus on combination preparations moving forward. I wonโt lower the rating, as it was my conscious decision to buy calcium citrate.
7.5
Normalised calcium levels
Excellent product! I ordered this for my mother, who is prone to kidney stones and had worsening osteoporosis. After about a year of use, her lab results showed normalised calcium levels and improved tests for bone metabolism, halting osteoporosis progression. A fantastic product!
9
No kidney stones
Drank for prevention. All is well. No kidney stones have arisen. Feeling good, you can take it.
9
Energy cycle assistance
1 people found this helpful
Excellent! Calcium citrate not only has high digestibility but offers numerous advantages. It reduces calcium excretion in urine, prevents kidney stones by alkalising urine, and aids in the absorption of vitamin C and minerals while participating in cellular energy cycles. I am pleased with my purchase and its benefits.
7.5
Highly absorbed calcium
3 people found this helpful
Good calcium! Calcium citrate is the optimal dosage form, absorbed by the body much better than calcium carbonate (which is more commonly sold in pharmacies). A key feature of calcium citrate is its low ability to form kidney stones, which is significant with prolonged use. As mineral salts are released from the body more quickly at night, it's advisable to take calcium supplements after lunch and in the evening. It's best to drink it with water and never tea!
7.5
Prevents kidney stones
4 people found this helpful
Best Absorbable Form of Calcium Why did I choose this particular calcium? Because my dietitian advised me to take calcium citrate as it is the least likely to contribute to the formation of kidney stones. This is the most optimal form of calcium. Additionally, the composition also contains vitamin D2, zinc, copper, magnesium and manganese. However, consider this if you are consuming other supplements to avoid overdose! It is recommended to take two tablets daily, ideally at different times. For instance, in the morning and afternoon. At night - it's not recommended, due to rapid mineral salt release from the body. Adults only should use this. The only drawback for me is the size of the oblong-shaped tablets - 2.4 cm long. I also struggle to swallow pills, needing to drink and eat to prevent choking on them. If my review is helpful, please like it ๐๐
9
Recommended for osteoporosis
5 people found this helpful
My mother has been taking this for six months, and she consumes one tablet daily for osteoporosis prevention. It works well and doesn't cause issues associated with other calcium forms. As a pharmacist, I recommend everyone choose calcium citrate to avoid potential kidney complications from inorganic salts that can lead to stones.
8
Magnesium supplements benefit kidney stone formers
Effect of magnesium oxide or citrate supplements on metabolic risk factors in kidney stone formers with idiopathic hyperoxaluria: a randomized clinical trial.
We evaluated how magnesium oxide and magnesium citrate supplements affect kidney stone formers with high oxalate levels. In a rigorous study with 90 participants, we found that both supplements helped lower oxalate excretion and calcium oxalate supersaturation when compared to a placebo.
Notably, magnesium citrate showed even stronger results, especially for those with normal urine magnesium levels. While both options are effective in reducing potential kidney stone risks, magnesium citrate may offer an edge in certain patients.
7
Calcium citrate lowers kidney stones
Pharmacotherapy and Stone Mineral Subtype Influence Long-Term Recurrence Rates in Calcium Stone Formers.
We investigated whether calcium citrate treatment helps prevent kidney stones over a long period. Our analysis followed patients with calcium stones for up to 12 years, focusing on how medical therapy, like calcium citrate, impacts stone recurrence.
We found that patients treated with calcium citrate, particularly those forming calcium-oxalate stones, showed lower recurrence rates after about five years. This delay in seeing benefits is crucial for understanding how we can plan future treatments.
8
Urinary factors impact kidney stone risk
24-Hour Urinary Chemistries and Kidney Stone Risk.
We undertook a thorough analysis of 24-hour urine collections from over 6,200 participants to explore how various urinary factors contribute to kidney stone formation.
Our findings revealed that higher levels of urine volume, citrate, potassium, magnesium, and uric acid were linked to a lower risk of developing stones. Conversely, increased levels of calcium, oxalate, phosphorus, and sodium were associated with a higher risk.
Interestingly, urine acidity did not seem to play a role. Our research highlighted the complexity and varying importance of these urinary factors regarding their relationship with stone formation.
7
Citrate beverage shows promise
Effect of a high-citrate beverage on urine chemistry in patients with calcium kidney stones.
We explored the effects of a low-calorie, high-citrate beverage named Moonstone on patients with calcium kidney stones. Administered twice daily, this drink increased urine citrate levels and pH while reducing calcium oxalate levels compared to plain water.
While this drink was well-received and tolerated by participants, the benefits seen are similar to those from potassium-magnesium citrate. Although promising, more research is needed to confirm its efficacy in reducing kidney stones in broader patient groups.
8
Combined therapies for kidney stones
Synergistic inhibition of calcium oxalate crystal formation and synergistic protection of HK-2 cells from crystal damage by sulfated polysaccharide and potassium citrate.
We investigated how combining sulfated polysaccharides with potassium citrate could inhibit calcium oxalate (CaOx) crystal formation and protect kidney cells.
Our study utilized various additive groups to compare their effectiveness. Excitingly, the combination of sulfated compounds and potassium citrate showed an impressive increase in their protective effects on renal cells and their capability to prevent crystal aggregation.
Particularly, the SDLP-Kcit combination stood out as an effective option for treating kidney stones, outpacing standalone treatments. This suggests a promising avenue for future kidney stone therapies.
References
Taheri M, Jalali S, Borumandnia N, Tavasoli S, Basiri A, et al. Effect of magnesium oxide or citrate supplements on metabolic risk factors in kidney stone formers with idiopathic hyperoxaluria: a randomized clinical trial. Magnes Res. 2024;37:12. 10.1684/mrh.2024.0524
Ruchi R, Di Valerio EA, Bozorgmehri S, Bacchus MW, Canales BK, et al. Pharmacotherapy and Stone Mineral Subtype Influence Long-Term Recurrence Rates in Calcium Stone Formers. Kidney360. 2024;5:1333. 10.34067/KID.0000000000000526
Ferraro PM, Taylor EN, Curhan GC. 24-Hour Urinary Chemistries and Kidney Stone Risk. Am J Kidney Dis. 2024;84:164. 10.1053/j.ajkd.2024.02.010
Goldfarb DS, Modersitzki F, Asplin JR, Nazzal L. Effect of a high-citrate beverage on urine chemistry in patients with calcium kidney stones. Urolithiasis. 2023;51:96. 10.1007/s00240-023-01468-w
Liu JH, Ouyang JM. Synergistic inhibition of calcium oxalate crystal formation and synergistic protection of HK-2 cells from crystal damage by sulfated polysaccharide and potassium citrate. Biomater Sci. 2023;11:3524. 10.1039/d3bm00087g